Skip to main content

How new whistleblowing rules affect businesses

Share

Major changes to legislation protecting workplace whistleblowers have significant implications for employers. Harrison Drury’s Employment law team, discusses the main issues for businesses need to be aware of.

Whistleblowing is the reporting of a suspected wrongdoing at work and employees have automatic legal protection against unfair dismissal if they are fired or if they are less favourably treated after making a ‘protected disclosure’ which includes:-

  • Health and safety risks
  • Damage to the environment
  • Criminal offence by an employer
  • A company failing to honour its legal obligations
  • Covering up a wrongdoing.

The public interest ‘elephant in the room’

On 25 June 2013 an extra test for protected disclosures was introduced. This means whistleblowers must now show that they ‘reasonably believe’ their disclosure is in the ‘public interest’ – a term not defined in law.

This lack of a definition is less of an issue for employers than might be imagined because the crux of the matter is whether whistleblowers can establish that they had a ‘reasonable belief’ that they acted in the public interest.

In cases where the public interest is in doubt, the general consensus is that the ‘elephant test’ will be applied by the courts– in other words, ‘you will know it if you see it’.

In good faith?

Another major change is that employees no longer need to make disclosures in ‘good faith’. Although there has been some concern among employers about the abolition of this requirement, tribunals can penalise the whistleblower by now reducing compensation by up to 25 per cent if the disclosure was not made in good faith.

It should also be kept in mind that employees will still be encouraged to broach issues firstly with their employer.

Just as importantly, protection for broader disclosure – notably going to the media – is only available if the issue is very serious, or if the whistleblower has already made a disclosure to their employer or a ‘prescribed person or body’, for example HM Revenue & Customs or the Serious Fraud Office.

The need to consider victimisation

The new law additionally means employers will be indirectly or ‘vicariously’ liable if other workers victimise a whistleblower. This aligns the law in this area with general discrimination law where employers are held responsible for the acts of their workers.

Good news or bad news for employers?

Although time will tell, the new rules place an additional hurdle in the way of whistleblowers as they must establish they reasonably believe the disclosure is in the public interest.  To that extent the changes are not entirely unwelcome for employers – and may in fact create a more efficient and transparent legal framework.

If you require more information on the law surrounding whistleblowing, or any other employment law matter, contact our Employment team on 01772 258321.


Questions & Answers

Leave a Comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


x

Manage your privacy

How we handle your personal data

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) gives you more control over how companies like ours use your personal information and makes it quicker and easier for you to check and update the information we hold about you.

As part of our service to you, we will continue to collect, use, store and share your data safely and securely. This doesn’t require any action on your part.

For more detailed information view our Privacy Hub